As fewer owners volunteer to serve, we are increasingly asked whether an association may pay its directors for their time. Board service can be a thankless job. Directors must oftentimes field owner complaints, review contracts, attend evening meetings, and make difficult financial decisions, usually for free.  This is not to mention that board members suffer the wrath of owners when anything goes wrong.

Given the above, it is understandable why many owners refuse to serve on their boards; as a result, questions are sometimes raised about offering directors a stipend or other form of compensation to attract and retain good leadership.

Although Colorado law does not prohibit director compensation, paying directors can carry legal and practical consequences every board should understand before cutting the first check.

 

What Does Colorado Law Say?

Most Colorado associations are nonprofit corporations governed in part by the Colorado Revised Nonprofit Corporation Act (“Nonprofit Act”). Under the Nonprofit Act, unless the bylaws provide otherwise, the board may authorize and fix the compensation of directors. The Colorado Common Interest Ownership Act (“CCIOA”) does not separately address the issue.

In practice, however, governing documents will oftentimes address this issue. Some governing documents, particularly older ones, expressly prohibit director compensation and allow only reimbursement of reasonable expenses. If your documents contain such a prohibition, an amendment will need to be passed before the directors can receive compensation for their service.

 

The Hidden Costs of Compensation

The most significant consequence of director compensation is its potential effect on a director’s personal liability protections. Colorado gives volunteer directors several layers of protection. CCIOA provides that directors who are not appointed by the declarant are not liable for actions taken or omissions made in performing their duties, except for wanton and willful acts or omissions. A separate statute grants civil immunity to directors of qualifying nonprofit organizations who are not compensated on a salary or prorated equivalent basis.

In other words, a paid director may give up a layer of immunity an unpaid director enjoys and will find it harder to argue that he or she is simply a volunteer. Whether a particular immunity statute applies depends on the association’s tax status and other facts, so the board should consult legal counsel before adopting any compensation plan.

Compensation also raises insurance and tax questions. The board should confirm with its insurance representative that the directors and officers liability policy will continue to cover compensated directors and should ask the association’s accountant about tax reporting.

 

Alternatives Worth Considering

Before adopting a compensation program, the board should consider whether its goals can be met another way. Common alternatives include:

  • Hiring a professional community manager to take on the day-to-day work that is wearing directors down; and
  • Creating committees to spread the workload among more volunteers.

 

If your board is considering compensating its directors, or would like to know whether your governing documents allow it, please contact an Altitude attorney at [email protected] or at 303.432.9999.